The State of Florida v. John Lee

Trial
03/15/13 – 03/28/13

Case Number
11 CF 2152 NC
Status
Concluded - Verdict
Industry
Criminal Case
Practice Area
Criminal Law
Judge
Peter Dubensky
Court
Lynn N. Silvertooth Judicial Center
Jurisdiction
12th Judicial Circuit of Florida

Sign Up

Cart Purchase DVD

Case Summary

In this criminal litigation proceeding, Plaintiff State of Florida alleged John Lee of murdering his girlfriend Traci Nabergall and their neighbor Jason Salter. The plaintiff’s counsel argued that the jury should listen about John Lee’s prior arrest on charges of battery, domestic violence and an alleged earlier incident of domestic violence, because of which Nagerball had to visit the hospital.

The plaintiff was represented by attorneys Arthur Jackman, Mary-Catherine Fraivillig and Andrea McHugh. The defendant in this case, John Lee was represented by attorneys Jerome Meisner and Carolyn Schlemmer.

Outcome
Death Penalty

Sessions
Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.

March 19 - AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:00 00:00:00 General Case Activities
00:05:04 00:05:04 Witness Direct Examination Fraivillig, Mary-Catherine McDonald, Chad In Person
00:14:09 00:14:09 Witness Cross Examination Schlemmer, Carolyn McDonald, Chad In Person
00:14:33 00:14:33 General Case Activities
00:15:48 00:15:48 Witness Direct Examination Jackman, Arthur Hendrickson, Jessica In Person
00:27:05 00:27:05 Witness Cross Examination Meisner, Jerome Hendrickson, Jessica In Person
00:29:02 00:29:02 General Case Activities
00:29:50 00:29:50 Witness Direct Examination Jackman, Arthur Meuller, Ronald In Person
00:37:15 00:37:15 Witness Cross Examination Schlemmer, Carolyn Meuller, Ronald In Person
00:38:01 00:38:01 Witness Direct Examination Jackman, Arthur Gorn, Michael In Person
01:03:57 01:03:57 Break
01:19:25 01:19:25 Witness Direct Examination Jackman, Arthur Gorn, Michael In Person
01:52:53 01:52:53 Witness Cross Examination Schlemmer, Carolyn Gorn, Michael In Person
02:01:43 02:01:43 Witness Re-Direct Examination Jackman, Arthur Gorn, Michael In Person
02:04:39 02:04:39 Witness Direct Examination Fraivillig, Mary-Catherine Porter, Rhonda In Person
02:12:20 02:12:20 General Case Activities
02:18:46 02:18:46 Witness Direct Examination Fraivillig, Mary-Catherine Porter, Rhonda In Person
03:12:27 03:12:27 Witness Re-Direct Examination Fraivillig, Mary-Catherine Porter, Rhonda In Person
03:19:05 03:19:05 Witness Re-Cross Examination Schlemmer, Carolyn Porter, Rhonda In Person
03:20:21 03:20:21 End of Session
03:46:02 03:46:02 Witness Cross Examination Schlemmer, Carolyn Porter, Rhonda In Person
March 20 - PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
March 22 - PM Session
Other
March 22 - PM Session
Other

Parties & Attorneys

Plaintiff

State of Florida

Defense

Lee, John

Witnesses