- Plaintiff
- Gross, Linda
- Defense
- Johnson & Johnson
- Represented By:
- Jones, Christy (Butler Snow LLP)
- Gage, William (Butler Snow LLP)
In Re Pelvic Mesh/Gynecare Litigation
VERDICT
Trial
01/09/13 – 02/28/13
Summary
This was the first case to go to trial involving pelvic mesh products manufactured by Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Ethicon. Plaintiff Linda Gross claims the Prolift mesh she received to treat bladder control issues caused her pain and additional injuries, and could not be fully removed despite further surgery.
Outcome
Damages:2,350,000
Punitive: 7,760,000
- Plaintiff
- Defense
- Verdict
- $10,110,000
- Judge
- Carol Higbee
- Jurisdiction
- New Jersey Superior Court, Atlantic County
- Court
- Atlantic County Civil Courthouse
- Case Number
- 291 CT
- Industry
- Pharmaceutical
- Practice Area
- Products Liability
- Lay Witnesses
- Arnaud, Dr. Axel MD
- Benson, Dr. Kevin MD
- Ciarrocca, Scott
- Everett, Jeff
- Gross, Mrs. Linda
- Gross, Mr. Jeff
- Henderson, Matthew
- Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D.
- Jones, Scott
- Kammerer, Dr. Gene Ph.D.
- Lake, Ms. Jacalynn
- O'Bryan, Sean
- Owens, Dr. Charlotte MD
- Raders, Dr. James MD
- Retterath, Dr. Patrick MD
- Robinson, Dr. David MD
- Schneider, Mark
SESSIONS WITH Dr. Piet Hinoul M.D.
Select a lawyer
×Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D.
Select a Type
Select a Description
AM Session
Openings
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | 00:00:00 | Opening Statement | Slater, Adam | |||
| 01:45:32 | End of Session | ||||
| 01:45:14 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Openings
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Opening Statement | Jones, Christy | |||
| 01:26:34 | End of Session | ||||
| 01:25:23 | General Case Activities |
JAN
10
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
6 Chapters
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
6 Chapters
JAN
11
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:40 | Witness Direct Examination | Mazie, David | Likness, Dr. Clark M.D. | In Person | |
| 01:22:48 | Break | ||||
| 01:57:58 | Witness Direct Examination | Mazie, David | Likness, Dr. Clark M.D. | In Person | |
| 03:03:25 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
8 Chapters
JAN
14
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
4 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Cross Examination | Gage, William | Ciarrocca, Scott | In Person | |
| 01:04:08 | Break | ||||
| 01:25:42 | Witness Re-Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Ciarrocca, Scott | In Person | |
| 02:45:23 | End of Session |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
9 Chapters
JAN
15
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:43 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D. | In Person | |
| 01:32:37 | Break | ||||
| 01:55:21 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D. | In Person | |
| 02:44:47 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
9 Chapters
JAN
16
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:51 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Weber, Dr. Anne MD, MS | In Person | |
| 00:53:02 | Break | ||||
| 01:19:48 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Weber, Dr. Anne MD, MS | In Person | |
| 03:11:27 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:24 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Weber, Dr. Anne MD, MS | In Person | |
| 00:48:10 | Break | ||||
| 01:10:26 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Weber, Dr. Anne MD, MS | In Person | |
| 02:29:58 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
JAN
17
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
8 Chapters
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
6 Chapters
JAN
18
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:49 | Witness Direct Examination | Mazie, David | Pence, Dr. Peggy PhD | In Person | |
| 00:50:43 | Break | ||||
| 01:36:01 | Witness Direct Examination | Mazie, David | Pence, Dr. Peggy PhD | In Person | |
| 02:43:22 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
7 Chapters
JAN
22
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
6 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:13 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:05:09 | Break | ||||
| 01:27:08 | Witness Cross Examination | Sutherland, Kari | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:21:37 | Witness Re-Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:38:18 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
JAN
23
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
7 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:04:24 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | O'Bryan, Sean | Video Recording | |
| 00:35:37 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Fiegen, Dr. Michael MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:13:27 | Break | ||||
| 01:26:14 | Witness Cross Examination | Crawford, Kelly | Fiegen, Dr. Michael MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:50:00 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 01:49:23 | Witness Cross Examination | Crawford, Kelly | Fiegen, Dr. Michael MD | Transcript Reading |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
8 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:03 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Schott, Susan PhD | Video Recording | |
| 01:02:39 | Break | ||||
| 01:20:42 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Schott, Susan PhD | Video Recording | |
| 01:45:18 | Witness Cross Examination | Gage, William | Schott, Susan PhD | Video Recording | |
| 02:37:07 | Witness Re-Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Schott, Susan PhD | Video Recording | |
| 02:41:29 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 02:40:56 | General Case Activities |
JAN
24
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
7 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:04 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Owens, Dr. Charlotte MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:12:21 | Break | ||||
| 01:47:33 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Owens, Dr. Charlotte MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:07:29 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Retterath, Dr. Patrick MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:49:24 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 01:46:51 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
JAN
25
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
12 Chapters
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
8 Chapters
JAN
28
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
JAN
29
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
7 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
JAN
30
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Gross, Mrs. Linda | In Person | |
| 01:11:25 | Break | ||||
| 01:32:28 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Gross, Mrs. Linda | In Person | |
| 01:55:06 | Witness Cross Examination | Jones, Christy | Gross, Mrs. Linda | In Person | |
| 02:37:35 | End of Session |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
9 Chapters
JAN
31
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
11 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
FEB
1
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
4 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Anderson, Benjamin | Klinge, Dr. Uwe Ph.D., M.D. | In Person | |
| 00:40:11 | Break | ||||
| 01:27:26 | Witness Direct Examination | Anderson, Benjamin | Klinge, Dr. Uwe Ph.D., M.D. | In Person | |
| 03:02:19 | End of Session |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
8 Chapters
FEB
4
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
6 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Robinson, Dr. David MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:04:27 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Jones, Scott | Video Recording | |
| 01:15:29 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Everett, Jeff | Video Recording | |
| 01:19:35 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Lake, Ms. Jacalynn | Video Recording | |
| 01:44:05 | End of Session | ||||
| 01:02:37 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
10 Chapters
FEB
5
AM Session
Defense Witness(es)
4 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Jones, Christy | Murphy, Dr. Miles MD | In Person | |
| 01:25:31 | Break | ||||
| 01:49:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Jones, Christy | Murphy, Dr. Miles MD | In Person | |
| 02:31:47 | End of Session |
PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
4 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Cross Examination | Slater, Adam | Murphy, Dr. Miles MD | In Person | |
| 01:28:57 | Break | ||||
| 01:52:05 | Witness Cross Examination | Slater, Adam | Murphy, Dr. Miles MD | In Person | |
| 02:32:36 | End of Session |
FEB
6
AM Session
Defense Witness(es)
9 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
FEB
7
AM Session
Defense Witness(es)
5 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Jones, Christy | Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D. | In Person | |
| 00:43:31 | Break | Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D. | In Person | ||
| 02:57:51 | Witness Direct Examination | Jones, Christy | Hinoul, Dr. Piet M.D. | In Person | |
| 03:23:38 | End of Session | ||||
| 02:57:21 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
7 Chapters
FEB
8
AM Session
Defense Witness(es)
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Raders, Dr. James MD | Video Recording | |
| 00:44:12 | End of Session |
PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
7 Chapters
FEB
11
AM Session
Defense Witness(es)
6 Chapters
PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
11 Chapters
FEB
12
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
FEB
13
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence |
|---|
FEB
14
AM Session
Closings
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:24 | Closing Statement | Jones, Christy | |||
| 02:07:44 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Closings
5 Chapters
FEB
15
AM Session
Other
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:41:04 | End of Session |
PM Session
Other
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:00:58 | End of Session |
PM Session
Other
7 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:35 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:00:32 | Witness Cross Examination | Crawford, Kelly | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 01:06:16 | Break | ||||
| 01:32:46 | Witness Cross Examination | Crawford, Kelly | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:19:28 | Witness Re-Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Benson, Dr. Kevin MD | Video Recording | |
| 02:35:21 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
FEB
19
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
PM Session
Other
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:02:51 | End of Session |
FEB
20
AM Session
Other
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:29 | Witness Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Gross, Mrs. Linda | Transcript Reading | |
| 01:02:35 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Other
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Witness Cross Examination | Jones, Christy | Gross, Mrs. Linda | Transcript Reading | |
| 00:56:39 | Witness Re-Direct Examination | Slater, Adam | Gross, Mrs. Linda | Transcript Reading | |
| 01:02:24 | End of Session |
PM Session
Other
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:00:28 | End of Session |
FEB
21
PM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
FEB
22
AM Session
Verdict
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Reading of the Verdict | ||||
| 00:06:16 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:03:46 | General Case Activities |
PM Session
Verdict
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:05:42 | End of Session |
FEB
25
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence |
|---|
AM Session
Openings - Damages
9 Chapters
PM Session
Defense Witness(es) - Damages
13 Chapters
FEB
26
AM Session
Other
2 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | General Case Activities | ||||
| 00:00:38 | End of Session |
FEB
27
AM Session
Verdict - Damages
3 Chapters
| Description | Attorney | Witness | Presence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00:00:00 | Reading of the Verdict | ||||
| 00:07:04 | End of Session | ||||
| 00:04:37 | General Case Activities |
FEB
28
Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.